GenAI is good for marketing strategy, but not in the way you might think. I discovered this on our first GenAI visibility/discoverability optimisation (GEO) project for a client.

SEO vs GEO

SEO was mostly based on keyword selection, placement and frequency. GEO is mostly based on website’s data structure, business categorisation and validation. The latter is key for this discussion. GenAI actively seeks to validate claims made by a brand or company elsewhere on the Internet. There’s no gas-lighting of unsupported benefits. It is not fooled by price discounting a weak benefit or position.

Old-fashioned GEO

The fastest, easiest way to GEO is to use an AI-based service or website plugin to do the work for you. This results in on-going subscription fees, and when you move away from the GEO service, you can lose some or all of your optimization. We decided to revise our client’s website manually, using the same GenAI platforms we needed to be discovered by for guidance. A strong GEO foundation makes on-going updates manageable.

The epiphany

Our client’s business success to date is based on specialisation of key industry verticals. As soon as we applied that thinking to GEO, we were able to put our client at the top of GenAI citations, in the context of the most desirable verticals. It’s not that Coyote or our client didn’t remember that vertical focus has been the key to past success. The GEO process helped us understand vertical focus—and finding new profitable verticals—is also the key to future growth.

The listicle problem

Of course, whenever you give someone the opportunity to game the system, on the Internet or in life, they will do it. See MW post SEO & GAMING THE ALGORITHM.

Enter the Listicle—those ‘Top 10 in 2026’ posts that search engines rank and GenAI uses for validation. Except despite its prodigious knowledge base and super-human logical reasoning ability, GenAI doesn’t always check the listicle’s basis of authority. We noticed one particular listicle being frequently cited as a reason our client wasn’t being discovered. That list, which included most of the big competitors in our client’s business category, was created by and posted on the website of a WordPress plugin developer. The developer’s product had nothing to do with our client’s business category. I contacted the owner of the website and was informed our client could be added to their listicle, for a price. The WordPress plugin business must really be tough. The above epiphany solved our listicle problem.

“

Think of GEO as welcome validation of a logic-based brand positioning in a current marketing world awash in emotion and distinctiveness.”

The takeaway

GenAI will happily write your brand or business strategy, and this this point in time, can be confidently wrong  [1] in doing so. Use GenAI for research and assisting with marketing communications execution. It’s the best use of its current capabilities. You focus on marketing strategy and the marketing mix beyond communications.

GenAI’s strategic value is not in generating strategy for you, it’s in forcing strategic discipline on you. Think of GEO as welcome validation of a logic-based brand positioning in a current marketing world awash in emotion and distinctiveness  [2].

Marketing communications creative is where emotion should live. Strategy is where logic should live.end-of-post-symbol

Notes and references:

  1. First used in a GenAI context by Axios journalist Ina Fried in December 2, 2022 column titled, ‘The smartest AI is dumb without people’.
  2. The roots of ‘distinctiveness’ as a marketing term are almost 20 years old, back to Byron Sharp’s wife Anne, who was also part of the Ehrenberg-Bass Institute.